Cranial (anterior) Cruciate Ligament Injury
Cranial cruciate ligament
injuries are common in dogs. The cranial cruciate ligament is analogous
to the anterior cruciate ligament in people and functions to stabilize
the knee joint during weight bearing. When cranial cruciate ligament
injuries were first described in dogs, they were characterized
as a traumatic injury with a mechanism of injury similar to people.
As our experience with cranial cruciate ligament injuries evolved,
we recognized that concurrent conditions such as patellar luxations,
hypothyroidism, and immune mediated arthritis could predispose
patients to a cranial cruciate ligament rupture. These conditions
can lead to abnormal stress or progressive weakening of the ligament.
Over recent years we are
seeing an epidemic of young (1-3 years old) medium to large breed
dogs with cranial cruciate ligament ruptures. Close scrutiny at
surgery demonstrates moderate to severe arthritic changes incompatible
with the time course represented by the history. Evaluation of
radiographs (x-rays) of the knee joint demonstrates an excessive
caudal tibial slope. We believe the excessive caudal tibial slope
predisposes dogs to a cranial cruciate ligament injury. An excessive
caudal tibial slope places additional stress on the cranial cruciate
ligament. Generally, when structures in the body are placed under
loads, those structures tend to get stronger. In this situation,
it seems that the additional load results in progressive weakening
of the ligament. There is a plausible explanation for this situation.
When we look at cartilage as a structure, its biomechanical properties
are such that cartilage can withstand an enormous amount of compression.
Cartilage does not, however, tolerate shear stress. An excessive
caudal tibial slope subjects cartilage to chronic shear stress.
In time the shear stress leads to fatigue fracture of the superficial
zone of cartilage and activation of cartilage cells to increase
turnover of cartilage by IL-1 and TNF (substances that produce
inflammation in the body). The activated cartilage cells are attempting
to repair the fatigue failure of the cartilage by increasing proteoglycan
and collagen production. The repair process of cartilage is ineffective
and resembles the repair process in other areas of the body. This
ineffective healing process creates a vicious cycle that leads
to osteoarthritis. In this environment of osteoarthritis, the overloaded
cranial cruciate ligament progressively weakens and eventually
ruptures.
Diagnosis of a cranial cruciate
ligament injury is based on physical examination findings of pain
localized to the stifle, joint effusion, medial buttress (scar
tissue) formation, and detection of instability in the joint (cranial
drawer sign). The cranial drawer sign is not always present in
dogs with a cranial cruciate ligament injury. This can occur because
of an uncooperative patient, interposed meniscal tissue, chronic
fibrosis of the joint, or a partial tear of the ligament.
Treatment Options
There are two broad categories of treatment for cranial cruciate
ligament injuries: Surgical forms of therapy and conservative management.
Conservative management of cranial cruciate ligament injuries is
centered on three basic principles: 1. Weight control. 2. Exercise
moderation. 3. Controlling pain with anti-inflammatory medication.
Maintaining your pets body weight at or slightly below the ideal
level will reduce the load placed on the joint and may improve function.
Restriction of activity for 6 weeks following the injury, then instituting
an exercise regime that avoids extremes of activity but maintains
muscle mass, helps avoid re-injury. Oral anti-inflammatory medication
will help control painful episodes. Overall, the outcome associated
with conservative management of cranial cruciate ligament injuries
is based on body size. Approximately 70-80% of small breed dogs and
cats will return to acceptable levels of function over a 6-week period
of time. Conversely, only 15-20 % of dogs over 30 lbs. will return
to acceptable function. Therefore, for medium to large breed dogs
that are very active, surgery is generally recommended.
Over the years, various surgical
techniques for repair of a cranial cruciate ligament injury in
dogs have been described and are composed of intra-articular repairs
and extra-articular repairs. Intra-articular repairs are modeled
after repairs in people and are designed to replace the ruptured
ligament with a graft of fascia or patellar tendon. Extra-articular
repairs are designed to replace the function of the cranial cruciate
ligament by placing a heavy suture (usually fishing leader) on
the outside of the joint in the same plane as the cruciate ligament.
The outcome associated with intra-articular and extra-articular
techniques is similar with 70-80% of patients returning to acceptable
function (sound at a walk and occasional limping or lameness after
activity). There is a substantial risk of re-injury to the repair
technique. Most patients will have recurrence of instability and
this instability is painful in 20-30% of patients. Additionally,
there is progression of arthritic changes. This is likely a result
of the continued shear stress on the cartilage as a result of the
excessive caudal tibial slope and the loss of range of motion caused
by exuberant scar tissue formation. In terms of strength of the
repair, intra-articular repairs and intra-articular repairs are
largely inadequate when compared to the normal strength of the
cranial cruciate ligament. When subjected to the continued load
created by the excessive caudal tibial slope it is not surprising
that there is recurrence of instability and progression of arthritic
changes.
Tibial Plateau Leveling
Osteotomy (TPLO)
The tibial plateau leveling osteotomy is a unique approach
for treatment of cranial cruciate ligament rupture. The TPLO biomechanically
eliminates the need for the cranial cruciate ligament by leveling
the tibial plateau thus eliminating the excessive caudal tibial
slope. The result is a dynamically stable joint. In addition, by
eliminating the excessive caudal tibial slope, the forces acting
on the cartilage surface are normalized from a shear force to compression,
which will limit the progression of arthritis and may facilitate
early cartilage recovery. The outcome following the TPLO is characterized
by early return to weight-bearing function and a durable lifelong
repair. Greater than 95% of patients will return to normal levels
of function. There is little chance of disruption of the repair
once the bone is healed.

|